Hey Guys! I know I'm asking for the impossible but could you possibly shed some light as to why
OK, this may have just bothered me, but why isn't Belichick running Ridley more? I mean watching the Dolphins game Bolden and Blount would run for 2 yards then Ridley would come in and run for 5. Is this because of Ridley's injury or what?
Ridley’s role on the offense has been an interesting topic in recent weeks. Given limited opportunities the theoretical lead back (he’s only started three games this fall) has run well. Ridley has averaged 4.5 yards a carry or better in each of the last three games and in five of the seven games he’s played in this season. But he’s topped 15 carries just twice in those games. Midway through the season he has just one 20-carry effort. In fact he’s passed 18 carries just once, a mark he surpassed 10 times last fall and four times in the first half of the season on the way to 1,200 yards. While he did miss the Week 5 game in Cincinnati to injury, Ridley was not listed on the injury report this past week. That’s why some speculated that his absence from the field in the first half against the Dolphins was disciplinary following what CBS analyst Dan Dierdorf called “hot-dogging” on Ridley’s 17-yard touchdown last week in New York. Ridley denied that idea and Belichick deflected the topic. Regardless, for an offense that’s struggling to find consistency and playmakers Ridley has been one of the team’s most effective players for the last month and yet hasn’t really seen his role increase. I understand that the running back group is a relatively deep one, even with
I think the Patriots need to give my boy Brady some fast WR that can catch like Kenny Britt and Emmanuel Sanders. Give Kenny Britt a chance to play with the best team in the NFL. I believe he has showed that he can catch and play and that’s what the Patriots need, experience.
Clearly the Patriots were looking into trades for wide receivers leading into today’s NFL trading deadline. There was too much reported smoke – including from guys like current NBC analyst and former Patriots VP of player personnel Scott Pioli – for there to be nothing to the various reports. Tennessee’s Britt, Pittsburgh’s Sanders, New York’s Hakeem Nicks and Cleveland’s Josh Gordon were some of the names being speculated. Britt and Gordon have clear off-field issues and are a misstep away from a long NFL suspension. Nicks would probably take a second-round pick to get done, if the Giants are even willing to deal. Sanders is interesting as the Patriots inked him to a restricted free agent contract offer last spring. Given the health and inconsistency of the receivers at this point, adding a weapon is a clear possibility. Will it happen? Who will it be? We’ll find out later today. ESPN’s Adam Schefter called the Patriots “a team to watch” heading into this afternoon’s trading deadline. So that’s what we’ll all be doing.
Seems like a lot of people are writing in about possible trades before the deadline. However it seems like almost all are concerned with WRs or at least offensive skill positions. Given that the D has been devastated by injuries why not shop Mallet to a team in need (CLE, JAX, HOU, CHI) for a solid DT, DE, or NT? Makes sense to me; Kelly's out, Wilfork's the man but gettin' up in age and Jones is the only real talent left on the line. It'd be great to see some more talent down there with him and does anyone really think Mallet is Brady's successor?
I agree that the area that might actually need the most help would be defensive tackle. Kelly remains injured.
Hey fellas, greetings from Toronto. Huge Pats fan and love the ask PFW segment. So it looks like Wes Welker is having the last laugh, he's enjoying a fantastic season in Denver. His replacement Danny "always injured" Amendola has been exactly what his history shows. Injured. In your opinions, do you think this year was a wakeup call for Pats management to not try to fix what isn't broken? ie: Branch, Welker, Seymour etc.. Maybe this season is Karma coming back to the bite them in the butt. I'd like to your honest "Pats fan" thoughts.
Thanks Jimmy Pops
I’m not really sure that anything that’s happened, including the Welker departure, will change the overall philosophy and decision making that goes on in New England. I think Belichick and the Patriots have always tried to be forward-thinking and value-based in their team building. Compounded by the loss of Aaron Hernandez and the early season injury to
Would a trade for Jermichael Finley be too much of a risk or would it cost the team too much to get him? And if not him Marcedes Lewis or Jordan Cameron wouldn't be a bad choice. And for either one of those two we shouldn't have to give up to much.
Yes, Finley would be a huge risk right now. He just got out of the hospital after a spinal contusion. He may still have to have surgery for the issue. No thanks. I’m also not that interested in Lewis or Cameron. Lewis is an underachiever who’s missed five games this fall with a calf injury, although I understand that the quarterback situation is obviously a big issue in that underachieving. Cameron is having a great year and I’m not sure why the Browns would trade him as they rebuild. Most importantly, I wouldn’t put tight end at the top of the Patriots needs right now. Rob Gronkowski is back and looks pretty healthy at this point to me. If I could snag Lewis for a mid-round pick I might do that deal. Otherwise I’d be looking for a defensive tackle, cornerback or wide receiver first.
Greetings from Wyoming, long time reader, first time inquirer. I was wondering why
Boyce has been third in the line of rookie receivers behind
What do you think the chances are of picking up another receiver such as Chad Johnson or Terrell Owens?
Slim and none. But slim is on IR with no designation to return.
Amendola is the biggest bust in Belichick's career. He flushed the fourth ring down the toilet. Can we unload him in 2014? Talib is great because he wasn't inculcated to play loose D from BB.
Clearly Amendola has dealt with injuries early in his time in New England, but I’m not ready to give up on his entire five potential seasons with the team. When out there he’s had a pretty good rapport with Brady and made some plays. Maybe the injury bug is finally in the past for him. You certainly could unload him next year if you wanted, although there would be cap ramifications in the range of a $5 million acceleration. And I don’t know why you would want to do that at this point. As for Talib, he’s a pure man coverage corner with first-round talent. To me, that’s what’s made him so good. The Patriots haven’t had that since Ty Law, who was also really good. I don’t really buy that the defensive coaching has ruined the cornerbacks that have made their way through New England in recent years and failed. It’s not like many of them have gone on to dominate in other places, with Darius Butler the only guy to really find any sort of success elsewhere.
…Is an old, damaged-goods linebacker who now does TV work for a living. I don’t really get the question. I certainly don’t think he could help the Patriots at this point, if that’s what you’re trying to ask.
I would argue that
I do think that Hoomanawanui has pretty good hands. But I’m not sure he offers much as a route runner or playmaker. Given the other weapons the team has and who are playing into health right now, I wouldn’t put Hooman too high on the list of options. That said, I think Brady could do worse than throwing in his direction every once in a while. But none of this has to do with his supposed stats at Illinois. Remember when we heard that Aaron Dobson supposedly didn’t’ drop a pass last year at Marshall? We’ve had plenty of fans of the Herd shoot that idea down and have seen Dobson drop plenty of throws early in his rookie season. So those supposed college “stats” are irrelevant.
You are confused, but not about the cap. The Patriots have the room under the cap to make a trade if they want to, and creating cap space is also generally pretty easy with some contract tweaking. But you see, it takes two sides to trade. You can’t just take a great player from another team. Why would the Cardinals just look to unload Fitzgerald? While there have been reports that the elite receiver could be traded this offseason, I think it’s going to take a pretty solid package to get it done. It’s not as easy as snapping your fingers and making it happen, as you seem to make it sound.
Where was Kenbrell Thompkins against the Dolphins? Was he hurt or just inactive to make room for Amendola?
Thompkins saw limited snaps against Miami, as has been the case for him the last couple weeks. He as active, but it was the first game this season in which he did not catch a pass and was only targeted on one Brady throw. With
I have never really been impressed with Cannon’s work at either tackle or guard in his two-plus seasons in New England, including preseason action. But given that he replaced Vollmer against Miami it looks like the former fifth-round pick is going to get the first shot at the right tackle job. It’s make-or-break time for him. Svitek is a proven veteran with starting experience at the tackle spot. I liked what I saw from him for the most part in the preseason. I’m sure he’s ready if Cannon falters, and I don’t think Belichick would hesitate to make a change if necessary for a line that’s frankly already been struggling even with Vollmer in the lineup early this season.
Dear Mr. McDaniels, RUN THE BALL. Our passing game is clearly struggling, yet our run game seems to be doing well. Why aren't we running the ball more?
As I said earlier, I would like to see the Patriots run the ball earlier and more frequently as the passing game continues to struggle through inconsistency. That might also be more of an issue if Brady is dealing with some injuries. McDaniels has talked about wanting to be balanced as much as possible. But when you included sacks and attempted passes, the Patriots have dropped back to throw 330 times this year compared to 232 runs. That’s not balanced, especially considering the failures of the passing game. It’s actually very similar to the “pass-happy” Broncos (347 to 234), who are actually having impressive success through the air. The backfield is relatively deep. Ridley looks like he’s running well of late. The offensive line wants to run block. I don’t really know why the game plan hasn’t been a little more swayed toward the run. The only reason to point to would be the fact that New England has always been a weekly game plan team that tries not to attack a defense’s strength. Teams like Cincy, the Jets and Miami all sported solid run defenses over the last month.
Last year BB did what was best for the team -- got
As we come upon the trading deadline, I’m not sure whether it’s hard for Belichick to make a deal or not. We’ll have to see it play out. But in general I think it’s difficult to trade in the NFL. There are lots of factors at play including salary cap, scheme fit and the short nature of the season relating to teams being “buyers or sellers.” I would love to see a veteran defensive tackle be added to the middle of the defense, a guy with the ability to play stout against the run. I didn’t expect Belichick to add Talib last fall. Maybe you’ll be happily surprised with what he does this time around.
With all the hype and chat around injuries, Tom Brady's hand and Gronkowski, I think you should mention the amazing, in the wings steady year, Gostkowski is having. He’s 20/21 on field goals, almost half the team’s points and some big pressure kicks. He’s keeping us in this thing Just look at the momentum shift after the Dolphins kicker hit the upright. 2013’s forgotten man!
Gostkowski is having a great year and it’s something we’ve talked about often in the pages of PFW. This also comes after he had a pretty poor summer kicking the ball. He’s been dead on when it counted, including a career-long 15-kick success streak that remains active. With nine long field goals at this point he needs just two more to break Adam Vinatieri’s record for successful field goals longer than 40 yards in one season. Gostkowski has also been a weapon on kickoffs, tied for second in the NFL with 34 touchbacks in eight games. He’s certainly been an unsung hero in the team’s 6-2 start at the midway point of the season.
As we all know Belichick sometimes likes to play with players’ skill sets to have them play different positions. Do you think it’s possible for a player like
That was where most scouts projected Harrison coming out of Rutgers. He probably has room to put on a little bit of weight to his 6-3, 230-pound frame. He’s a big receiver with good strength, so I’m not sure the minimal blocking would be a major issue. He needs to get healthy and get on the practice field, but I could see Harrison in a sort of hybrid receiver role next summer looking to make a role for himself on a team that lost the versatile Aaron Hernandez this offseason.
Greetings!!! Big fan of yours from Missouri. I was wondering where you stand on part of the offensive woes being our offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels. I hear a lot of flak coming to Brady and the receivers but he seems to skate free of judgment. After watching the last three games and paying attention to the play calling we seem to always run the ball with
As I said above, McDaniels has talked about wanting to bring more balance back to the offense since he returned as the coordinator last year. Heck, he’s brought a fullback back into the mix. But that hasn’t played out in terms of play calling and production early this season. Part of that is that New England hasn’t had great success on first-and-10 runs among all the team’s backs. I don’t think the McDaniels skates, though. As someone who reads a lot of emails for Ask PFW and interacts with a lot of fans for our PFW in Progress radio show on Patriots.com, I can say that many fans have questioned the play calling, game plans and the job that McDaniels is doing. While McDaniels may be struggling like the entirety of the offense right now, I still think he’s a great offensive mind, good coach and very good play caller. He’ll turn it around. I’d bet on it.
There is no doubt that Belichick has a huge hand in the offensive game plan. I don’t think it could be any bigger. But I don’t think he has as much to do with the play calling and in-game offensive adjustments. Watching Belichick on the sideline he spends a lot of time with the defense, watching it when it’s on the field and coaching it when it’s on the bench. I also wonder how much time he spends at halftime making adjustments with the offense, or if he leaves most of that to McDaniels. The offense is struggling, there is no way around that. That puts pressure pretty much on everyone, including the coordinator. But let’s not pretend that Belichick isn’t among the most weighted voices putting together the game plan and personnel packages each week. It’s his team and he makes all the major decisions on both sides of the ball.
The "We want Larry Fitzgerald in New England" emails just can't be stopped. Do you think the Cardinals would consider sending Fitz to New England for Mallett and a draft pick? What pick would be equitable? Outside of Timmy "We don't want him back in New England" Tebow, who is on the back up market that is viable (e.g. has experience in our system, a similar one).
I don’t think there is a great backup option to add to the roster right now. Is Vinny Testaverde still upright? Doug Flutie? And I don’t think the Cardinals would even want Mallett heading into a draft class at the position that some people believe might be the best ever. If they were to deal Fitzgerald to New England I would guess it would be for a bounty of draft picks, including at least one first-rounder so they could take advantage of this year’s projected quarterback draft crop.
Hi guys. 6-2 halfway through, given the key injuries, and offensive inconsistency/bad play, is pretty darn good. Perhaps, even more remarkable, with a break or 2 this team could be 7-1, or 8-0. On the whole, hard to complain about the record.
I agree with the idea that it’s hard to complain about the record. Sitting pretty at the midway point. But I have to argue the “with a break or 2” logic. I think New England has had its share of breaks. In fact, I think you could just as easily argue that if a “break or 2” went the other way in the first eight games that this team could be 4-4. But it’s not. It’s 6-2. That’s a really good spot to be in. Enjoy it.
Please ask Bill to trade for Jared Allen who will help greatly with the current D-line issues and provide a nice line next year with Wilfork, Allen, Jones, maybe Carter/Ninkovich
I’ll try. But I’m not sure I’ll be able to get him that message in time for today’s NFL trade deadline. Darn it.
Ask the Writers A Question >>